Not logged in
 
Author
Topic: Golf Simulator Image Brightness
member
Joined: Dec 30, 2023
Posts: 1
Reply to PostAlert Moderator
Hello BS,

I’ve recently bought a golf simulator enclosure measuring 148.7” diagonal for my viewable space - impact screen.

I currently have a BenQ TH671ST - When using the Projector Central throw calculator with a 4:3 aspect ratio and 148” diagonal I get an Estimated image brightness FL score of 10. With some ambient lighting it does feel there is more to be desired with the TH671ST and the image feels not overly bright and crisp.

I was looking for various projectors using the same dimensions:

BENQ LH820ST - Got an FL score of 37
Optoma EH412SR - Got an FL score of 40

Based on my setup dimensions above - will I see a significant improvement with the LH820ST or Optoma above? Is there anything in the same price range that would score even higher? Thanks in advance for the help!

Cheers,
John
moderator
Joined: Mar 28, 2005
Posts: 13,305
Reply to PostAlert Moderator
It's basically impossible to know how much of a difference you are going to get going from one projector to another without real world testing of the models. The Optoma is rated to be about 33% brighter than the TH671ST. That's not actually a ton brighter.

But, the BenQ could have some hours on it, the lamp could have dimmed a bit, and it may not be running in it's absolute brightest mode, which can impact brightness a fair bit.

Not that the TH671 rating of 10 lumens per square foot is based upon REVIEW measurements (real world) vs. the manufacturer's specifications. So, you have a radio button you can click which makes the TH671 into 'manufacturers specs', which changes the number to 31 lumens per square foot.

The numbers are pretty typical, and I'd expect the Two models you list to be brighter, but I haven't seen them first hand and it's pretty tough to know how much brighter they will truly be in the real world. It wouldn't likely be a ton.

The best thing to do in any golf simulator setup, is to use spot lights over the golfer, and to do your best to make the screen area as absolutely dark as possible. This will meaan that most projectors will perform just fine and golfers will be able to see the ball just fine as well.

Foot lumens (FL) are a measure of brightness. Not really a score. Total rated light output of projector, divided by the square footage of screen equals the lumens per square foot (FL) result.
AV Integrated - Theater, whole house audio, and technology consultation during the build and installation process in the Washington, DC metropolitan area.